By the time Shams of Tabriz arrived in Konya, Jalaluddin Muhammad had already become the kind of man others traveled to meet.
Shams was different. He was the traveler.
He moved from place to place without the social machinery that surrounded established scholars. He had no great school carrying his name, no crowd waiting for his sermons, and little patience for status. Accounts of his life describe a wandering dervish who had spent years meeting theologians, teachers, and mystics, yet repeatedly came away with the feeling that something was missing.
He was searching for someone who could understand not merely his words, but the experience behind them.
That search eventually brought him to Rumi.
Perhaps the remarkable thing is that each man appears, at first glance, to possess what the other lacks. Rumi had structure, reputation, scholarship, students, and public authority. Shams had freedom from nearly all of them. Rumi knew how to inhabit the world of institutions. Shams seemed to prefer standing outside them and asking uncomfortable questions.
When they finally met, two very different approaches to knowledge collided.
History has preserved several accounts of that meeting. It is impossible to know with certainty which details belong to fact and which accumulated through retelling. Yet sometimes legends persist because they express the truth of a relationship better than a list of verified dates ever could.
One of the most famous begins with books.
The Books Beside the Water
According to the story, Rumi was sitting beside a pool with a number of manuscripts around him. In the thirteenth century, books were precious objects, copied by hand and often carrying histories of their own.
Shams approached and asked what the books contained.
Rumi supposedly replied that they contained knowledge Shams would not understand.
The response tells us something about how the story wishes us to see them at that moment. Rumi is the scholar, secure in learning. Shams is the stranger whose appearance gives little indication of intellectual pedigree.
Then Shams reaches for the books and throws them into the water.
Rumi is horrified. One account even says some of the manuscripts had belonged to his father. He demands to know what Shams has done.
Shams reaches into the water and removes the books.
They are dry.
Rumi, astonished, asks how this could be possible.
Shams returns his earlier words.
This is something you would not understand.
Whether books literally emerged dry from a pool is ultimately less interesting than why generations continued repeating the story.
The encounter places two kinds of knowledge beside one another.
There is knowledge that can be collected, organized, taught, and preserved between covers. Then there is another kind, encountered through experience, transformation, intuition, and the inner life.
Rumi had spent years accumulating the first.
Shams had arrived to ask whether there was another.
The story does not reject books. Rumi himself remained a scholar. Rather, it challenges the assumption that possessing knowledge about something is identical to experiencing it.
A person may know everything written about fire without ever having been burned.
Shams was about to bring Rumi much closer to the flame.
The Question of the Two Cups
Another tradition places a theological question at the center of their first encounter.
Shams asks Rumi about the Prophet Muhammad and the famous Sufi mystic Bayazid Bastami. The Prophet had acknowledged that God could never be known as fully as God deserved to be known. Bayazid, during states of mystical ecstasy, had made declarations that seemed to express complete spiritual absorption.
Shams asks Rumi which position represents the greater spiritual realization.
It is a dangerous question, particularly in the religious environment of the time. A careless answer could easily be misunderstood.
Rumi reportedly responded with an image.
Bayazid’s cup had filled and overflowed.
The Prophet’s cup continued expanding.
The point was not that the Prophet possessed less knowledge. The opposite. His capacity for knowing the divine was so vast, and continued to grow so profoundly, that greater knowledge only revealed the infinity that remained beyond it.
The metaphor is beautiful because it reverses one of our ordinary assumptions about expertise.
We imagine that learning should move us steadily toward certainty. Often, genuine learning does the opposite. The novice looks at a problem and sees a simple answer. The expert sees variables, dependencies, contradictions, and possibilities invisible from the surface.
Sometimes knowing more does not fill the cup.
It enlarges it.
According to the legend, Shams heard Rumi’s answer and immediately recognized something in him. Here, finally, was someone who understood the question.
Rumi, in turn, had encountered someone willing to ask questions that did not belong comfortably inside the normal boundaries of his lectures.
Their relationship began.
Konya would soon wish that it had not.
Behind Closed Doors
Rumi started withdrawing from public life.
The precise duration varies across accounts, but traditions describe months of intense companionship and seclusion between Rumi and Shams. One version places them in a house and garden associated with Salahuddin Zarkub, the goldsmith who had become one of Rumi’s companions.
The scholar who had once stood before packed gatherings began disappearing from them.
Students lost access to their teacher. Followers who were accustomed to hearing him preach found him increasingly unavailable. Contact with his household diminished. His eldest son, Sultan Walad, seems to have remained among those closest to the two men during this period.
It is not difficult to imagine how the situation appeared from outside.
A stranger had arrived in Konya and, within a remarkably short period, one of the city’s most respected scholars seemed to have abandoned the rhythm of the life everyone knew.
People blamed Shams.
This reaction is understandable even if it was unfair.
Communities develop a quiet sense of ownership over prominent people. Students feel they have a claim on the teacher. Institutions believe they have a claim on the scholar. Families have their own claims, often much more legitimate and painful. Followers become accustomed to access.
Then someone enters the person’s life and everything changes.
The newcomer becomes an easy explanation.
Shams was that newcomer.
Transformation From the Outside
We enjoy stories of transformation when we already know the ending.
Once the artist becomes famous, abandoning the conventional career appears brave. Once the entrepreneur succeeds, walking away from a secure position becomes visionary. Once the reformer changes history, refusing to conform seems inevitable.
While transformation is actually occurring, it often looks much less noble.
It can look foolish.
Selfish.
Irresponsible.
Even unstable.
The people of Konya did not know that centuries later Rumi would be read across the world. They could not see the future mystical poet whose words would survive empires.
They saw their scholar behaving strangely.
Some accounts suggest people believed he had lost his mind. Others claimed Shams had exercised some strange influence over him.
His family also lived with the consequences. Spiritual transformation may sound beautiful in retrospect, but it can be enormously disruptive to those standing nearby.
That tension should not be romanticized.
Rumi was changing, but other people had to absorb the effects of the change.
Shams, meanwhile, was not a particularly easy person to defend.
He appears in tradition as uncompromising, unpredictable, and deeply suspicious of outward displays of piety. He had little patience for religious prestige that was not matched by inner transformation.
One could perform every ritual and remain consumed by ego. One could become a great scholar and still use knowledge as a way of feeling superior to others. One could speak constantly of God without becoming kinder, humbler, or more compassionate.
For Shams, the question was not merely what you knew.
It was what knowing had done to you.
That question was transforming Rumi.
It was also making Shams enemies.
Konya Wants Its Scholar Back
The hostility intensified until eventually Shams left.
He seems to have departed without warning Rumi.
The effect was devastating.
Rumi became distraught and restless. The depth of his reaction revealed something that even those around him may not previously have understood. Whatever the people of Konya thought of Shams, he had become central to Rumi’s inner life.
Ironically, some of the same people who had resented Shams began regretting that he was gone.
They had wanted the old Rumi back.
Instead they were confronted with a grieving man.
Rumi began searching for his friend. News eventually reached him that Shams was in Damascus, one of the great centers of learning in the Islamic world. Rumi sent his son Sultan Walad to find him and persuade him to return.
Sultan Walad succeeded.
For a time, the story seemed to reverse itself.
Shams came back to Konya.
The companionship resumed. The conversations returned. This time Shams stayed within Rumi’s household, and Rumi increasingly treated him not simply as a companion but as a spiritual guide.
Yet the tensions that had driven Shams away had not disappeared.
They had merely been waiting.
The Second Disappearance
Rumi’s relationship with Shams remained difficult for others around him to accept. Later traditions describe particular resentment from Rumi’s second son, Alauddin, though the details surrounding the family conflict are difficult to establish with certainty.
What is clear is that opposition remained.
Then, around 1248, Shams disappeared for the second and final time.
The story is almost painfully simple.
Rumi and Shams are together.
Someone comes to the door and calls Shams outside.
Shams rises and leaves.
He does not return.
From that moment, the historical trail becomes uncertain.
One tradition claims Shams was murdered. Some accounts place responsibility among people in Rumi’s wider circle. Another story says his body was thrown into a well and later recovered. Shrines, local traditions, and later narratives have all preserved different versions of what may have happened.
There is no need to force certainty where history does not provide it.
For Rumi himself, uncertainty may have been part of the suffering.
Death, terrible as it is, eventually gives grief a fact around which it can form.
Disappearance leaves a question.
Where is he?
Is he alive?
Will he return?
Should I keep searching?
Rumi did.
And somewhere within that search, something changed again.
When the Search Turns Inward
At first, Rumi searched for Shams as a person who existed somewhere else.
Perhaps Damascus again.
Perhaps another city.
Perhaps somewhere beyond the reach of news.
But the longer he searched, the more a different realization emerged.
The Shams he was trying to recover had already altered him.
The questions remained.
The conversations remained.
The way of seeing remained.
Shams had become part of the inner architecture of Rumi’s mind.
Eventually, Rumi came to an extraordinary conclusion.
Shams was within him.
This should not be read as a claim that the two men literally became the same person. It was something more psychologically and spiritually interesting. Rumi realized that the transformation Shams had caused could no longer be separated from him.
The teacher had disappeared.
The teaching had not.
And now Rumi had to discover how to live without the physical presence of the person who had opened that door.
His answer came through poetry.
The respected theologian had written before, but now the language changed. Longing, absence, ecstasy, grief, love, and the search for the Beloved began pouring into verse.
Eventually thousands of those verses would form one of the great works associated with Rumi.
And then he did something remarkable.
He gave the collection another man’s name.
It became the Divan-e Shams-e Tabrizi.
The wandering dervish who had disappeared from Konya would remain present in the title of Rumi’s poetry for centuries.
Perhaps this is where the story of Rumi and Shams becomes larger than the mystery of what physically happened to Shams.
Shams had once said that if he found the person who truly understood him, he would give his head.
Whether his life literally ended because of that search may never be known.
But he did find Rumi.
And after he disappeared, something of Shams continued living inside the man he had changed.
Rumi had begun their relationship as a scholar surrounded by books.
He emerged from it as a poet trying to understand absence.
The teacher was gone.
The real lesson was only beginning.
Posts in this series:
- Before He Became Rumi: The Scholar Who Walked Away from Certainty
- When Rumi Met Shams: The Man Who Broke Open His World
- After Shams: The Rumi Who Remained (Coming Soon)
Other similar Posts:
- Zikr in Six Movements: On Sai by Satinder Sartaaj (Six-part series on Sai)
- Echoes of the Divine: Hamds, Naats & Qawwalis in Sufism
- Listening as Devotion: The Sufi World of the Wadali Brothers
๐๏ธ 2 views